|
2008:
GIC ISSUERS WEATHER UNPRECEDENTED MARKETING CONDITIONS - MANAGING THROUGH
THE CRISIS
Throughout
our twenty-two year history, FCM's stable value management approach
has primarily utilized diversified portfolios of traditional guaranteed
investment contracts (GICs) issued by major life insurance companies.
We have found several relative value advantages in using GICs over other
stable value products including policyholder status and superior yield
premiums relative to comparable high-grade obligations. In general,
GIC issuers represent the most creditworthy segment of a mature, highly
regulated industry that exhibits strong credit fundamentals including:
solid capital levels, diversified revenue and earnings sources, consistent
operating cash flows, and conservative balance sheets.
At
the start of 2008, GIC issuers were well positioned to weather the credit
crisis with historically strong credit fundamentals including robust
capital levels. As the credit crisis evolved, issuers generally fared
better than other financial institutions due to more stable liquidity/funding
needs and generally stronger balance sheets with lower exposures to
"toxic" assets.
|

David J. Molin,
CFA
Senior Vice President & Director of Research
Fiduciary Capital Management, Inc.
|
|
However,
the credit fundamentals of several issuers began to weaken in late 2008
as the credit market turmoil and unprecedented equity market declines
significantly depressed earnings and pressured capital levels. In response,
management teams have taken actions to shore up balance sheets including
capital raising initiatives, augmenting liquidity positions, and reducing
risk exposures. Overall, FCM considers these actions to be credit positive
and we expect management to implement more strategic initiatives including
divestitures of non-core businesses. In October, the rating agencies
changed their outlooks for the life insurance industry from stable to
negative, and several issuers have experienced downgrades. Overall,
these actions were not unexpected and most GIC issuers still retain
strong financial strength ratings.
As of year-end
2008, GIC issuer capitalization remained sound with statutory surplus
totaling $99.9 billion, down 10% from the historic high of $110.6 billion
in 2007. During 2008, issuer capital positions were negatively impacted
by depressed earnings and higher investment losses. As a result, the
median ratio of surplus to general account assets for FCM's GIC issuer
universe decreased from 9.7% to 7.7%, the lowest level since 2002. On
a risk-adjusted basis, capital ratios remained solid with our issuer
universe reporting an average NAIC Risk-Based Capital ratio of 414%,
significantly above regulatory minimums and down only modestly from
the historic high of 443% in 2007. Earnings results were dismal in 2008
with our issuer universe reporting an aggregate statutory net operating
loss and net loss of $1.8 billion and $15.7 billion, respectively. Overall,
earnings performance was negatively impacted by credit and equity markets
conditions resulting in significantly higher investment losses, lower
asset-based fee revenue, lower investment income, and higher reserves
for variable annuity (VA) guarantees. Of note, statutory accounting
understates the true earnings picture due to the fact that hedging gains
related to the VA business flow directly to capital and are not reflected
as income.
GIC issuers
have traditionally maintained high quality investment portfolios. Investing
activities are primarily focused in diversified bond portfolios representing
approximately 70% of invested assets. Bond portfolios are typically
comprised of 60% to 70% corporate bonds, with the remaining 20% to 30%
invested in structured securities including mortgage-backed and asset-backed
securities. In general, GIC issuer bond portfolios are conservatively
managed with over 90% invested in investment grade securities and significant
diversification by individual issuer and sector. As of year-end 2008,
below investment grade (BIG) bond holdings represented 7.2% of total
bonds on average, compared to just over 9% during the weak credit environment
in 2002. By the end of this credit cycle, FCM expects BIG holdings to
potentially surpass 2002 levels given recent rating agency downgrades
of certain mortgage related securities and the potential for substantially
higher levels of "fallen angels". After bond holdings, commercial
mortgages comprise the second largest investment allocation representing
12% of the average issuer's invested assets. In general, GIC issuers
have demonstrated expertise in managing this asset class and typically
invest in conservatively underwritten and well diversified mortgage
portfolios. This asset class has performed very well in recent years
with the average level of non-performing mortgages to total mortgages
at only 0.1% as of year-end 2008. Although the level of problem assets
is currently very manageable, the commercial real estate market is expected
to weaken significantly in 2009.
During
2008, GIC issuers experienced sizable investment losses largely driven
by the historic defaults within the financial sector and impairments
on structured securities. Going forward, FCM expects issuers to continue
to experience above average losses in the near term. However, the overall
impact on financial strength should be manageable given that most issuers
produce solid operating cash flows and maintain excess capital positions
to absorb losses. That said, we continue to face very uncertain times
with unprecedented volatility in the credit and equity markets along
with the possibility of an extended economic downturn, which we believe
will continue to challenge even the most creditworthy of financial institutions.
In summary,
we expect GIC issuers to continue to face short-term financial pressures
given the unprecedented market conditions; however, FCM believes that
long-term credit fundamentals remain favorable relative to high-grade
fixed income alternatives.
David
J. Molin, CFA
|